IBM Project Debater manipulation dangers
Occurred: March 2021
Can you improve this page?
Share your insights with us
The growing sophistication of IBM's Project Debater, an autonomous AI system that can debate competitively with humans, prompted concerns about the extent to which it could be manipulated in a real-world setting.
IBM researchers working on the project published a paper in Nature magazine in which they showed that Project Debater is capable of beating humans in debates. In a series of tests, the system was given 15 minutes to research topics and prepare for debates. Humans won most debates, but in one instance it was able to change the stance of nine people.
When tasked with a debate, Project Debater scans the internet for prior research, or quote well-known phrases used by people respected in the field of argument. It also uses IBM's Watson system to listen to the arguments given by opponents and then searches for rebuttals that have been given by others to similar claims.
In a Nature magazine editorial, University of Dundee's Chris Reed made the case for stronger oversight and greater transparency of language models such as Project Debater and OpenAI's GPT-3 in order to reduce the potential for manipulation and harm.
Databank
Operator: IBM
Developer: IBM
Country: Israel
Sector: Technology
Purpose: Debate with humans
Technology: NLP/text analysis; Sentiment analysis; Text-to-speech
Issue: Appropriateness/need; Dual/multi-use
Transpa: Governance; Black box
System
Slonim N. et al (2021). An autonomous debating system
Research, advocacy
Reed C. (2021) Argument technology for debating with humans
News, commentary, analysis
https://futurism.com/ai-designed-debate-people-ruin-social-media
https://techxplore.com/news/2021-03-ibm-ai-debating-expert-human.html
https://interestingengineering.com/ibm-ai-debates-humans-convinces-some
https://htxt.co.za/2021/03/ibms-project-debater-is-equal-parts-frightening-and-fascinating/
https://www.sciencealert.com/this-new-ai-exists-for-the-sole-purpose-of-arguing-with-humans
Page info
Type: Issue
Published: March 2021