Unconstrained College Students (UCSS)

Transparency and accountability 🙈

At the time, University of Colorado students had not been informed they were under surveillance nor were they told that images of them would be used to train military and intelligence agency facial recognition systems. 

In addition, no infomation was provided as to how they could opt-out or have their photographs removed from the system.

Risks and harms 🛑

The Unconstrained College Students (UCCS) dataset is seen to have significant transparency limitations.

• Lack of consent. Over 1,700 students and pedestrians were photographed using a long-range high-resolution surveillance camera without their knowledge or consent, raising ethical concerns about privacy and informed participation.

• Unclear data collection process. While some details are provided about the camera setup and timing of photos, the full extent of the data collection and curation process is not entirely transparent.

• Limited demographic information. The dataset lacks comprehensive information about the subjects' demographics, making it difficult to assess potential biases or representativeness.

• Restricted access. The dataset has been temporarily suspended, limiting the ability of researchers to independently verify or analyse its contents.

• Insufficient documentation. There appears to be a lack of clear guidelines or restrictions on how the dataset can be used, potentially leading to misuse or unethical applications of the biometric data.

• Funding sources. The dataset's creation was primarily funded by United States defense and intelligence agencies, which raises questions about the intended uses and potential biases in the data collection process.

• Lack of opt-out mechanism. The authors fail to provide any options for students to opt-out or be removed from the dataset, further compromising individual privacy rights.

Research, advocacy 🧮

• Cheng Z., Zhu X., Gong S. (2018). Surveillance Face Recognition Challenge

Investigations, assessments, audits 👁️

• Harvey, A., LaPlace, J. (2019). Exposing.ai

• Murgia M., Financial Times (2019). Who’s using your face? The ugly truth about facial recognition