DNA evidence is bungled in dozens of Queensland crimes
DNA evidence is bungled in dozens of Queensland crimes
Occurred: March 2015-
Report incident π₯ | Improve page π | Access database π’
DNA evidence was mishandled in thousands of criminal cases in Queensland, Australia, due to severe maladministration and flawed testing methods at the state's forensic lab, calling into question the integrity of the state's criminal justice system and the reliability of the technology involved.
An official inquiry revealed that DNA evidence was mishandled by the forensic lab in numerous cases. It also found that the lab had focused on speed over accuracy, leading to widespread failures in properly testing DNA samples for years.Β
The inquiry also found that STMmix, the method used for DNA testing, was found to have critical flaws, raising questions about the validity of the forensic evidence produced.Β
The flawed practices may have led to offenders escaping conviction and could affect the outcomes of numerous cases. The fracas was seen to highlight the broader impact of the forensic lab's failings on the criminal justice system, including the potential for wrongful convictions and the undermining of public confidence in forensic evidence.Β
β December 2022. Walter Sofronoff KC's final report (pdf) on Forensic DNA Testing in Queensland concludes the forensic lab suffered from poor leadership, oversight and practices, inadequate quality control, and significant errors in DNA testing processes.
β October 2023. Queensland announced it would open a fresh inquiry to investigate concerns about an automated DNA extraction method at the state's forensic lab relating to a process known as 'Project 13'.
Operator: Queensland Health Forensic and Scientific Services
Developer: Institute of Environmental Science; Research and Forensic Science South Australia
Country: Australia
Sector: Govt - police
Purpose: Interpret DNA mixtures
Technology:Β
Issue: Accountability; Accuracy/reliability; Robustness; Human/civil rights; Transparency
WALTER SOFRONOFF QC. Final Report. Commission of Inquiry into Forensic DNA testing in Queensland (pdf)
WALTER SOFRONOFF QC. REPORT CONCERNING USE BY QUEENSLAND HEALTH FORENSIC AND SCIENTIFIC SERVICES OF CERTAIN EVIDENTIARY STATEMENTS (pdf)
Queensland Health. STRmix Miscoding Error (pdf)
Page info
Type: Incident
Published: June 2024