Occurred: February 2012
Report incident 🔥 | Improve page 💁 | Access database 🔢
5th grade Washington DC public school teacher Sarah Wysocki was fired for receiving a poor evaluation by an algorithm, resulting in a heated controversy about the accuracy, fairness, value and transparency of the region's teacher performance evaluation system.
District of Columbia Public Schools' IMPACT teacher evaluation system used test scores from schools under investigation for cheating to calculate so-called 'value-added scores' that would be incorporated into teacher evaluations.
Wyosecki had earned excellent observation ratings and was highly regarded by peers and parents. But she received an uncharacteristically low value-added score and lost her job, despite evidence the evaluation generated by the algorithm was based on falsified student scores.
The algorithm is seen to have failed to account for various external factors affecting student performance, such as learning disabilities or poverty. And its proprietary nature made it difficult for Wysocki to challenge or understand the reasoning behind her low score.
Wyosecki's appeal against her dismissal failed, though she was quickly offered a position with another school system.
205 other teachers also lost their positions.
IMPACT 🔗
District of Colombia Public Schools. IMPACT: The DCPS Evaluation and Feedback System for School-Based Personnel
Operator: District of Columbia Public Schools
Developer: Mathematica Policy Research
Country: USA
Sector: Education
Purpose: Assess and rank teacher performance
Technology: Value-added model
Issue: Accountability; Accuracy/reliability; Bias/discrimination; Effectiveness/value; Transparency
Varma A., Dawkins C., Chaudhuri K. (2023). Artificial intelligence and people management: A critical assessment through the ethical lens
Alon-Barkat S., Busuioc M. (2023). Human–AI Interactions in Public Sector Decision Making: “Automation Bias” and “Selective Adherence” to Algorithmic Advice
Yan S. (2021). Algorithms are not bias-free: Four mini-cases
Education Writers Assocation (2012). One Teacher Feels Impact of ‘Value-Added’ Evaluations
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/teacher-evaluations_b_1328456
https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/when-value-added-scores-dont-make-sense/2012/03
https://qz.com/819245/data-scientist-cathy-oneil-on-the-cold-destructiveness-of-big-data/
https://blogs.ischool.berkeley.edu/w231/2018/12/11/impact-of-algorithmic-bias-on-society/
https://www.econtalk.org/cathy-oneil-on-weapons-of-math-destruction/
Page info
Type: Incident
Published: November 2021
Last updated: June 2024